Come up with a list of reasons an athlete might use a supplement

University courses Physical Sciences
1

The Goldman Dilemma

Goldman’s Dilemma refers to a hypothetical ethical dilemma faced by athletes, particularly in the context of professional sports and the use of performance-enhancing substances.

Dr. Robert Goldman, a physician and anti-doping advocate conducted a survey in 1982, asking elite athletes if they would take a performance-enhancing substance that guaranteed them victory in their sport but came with a condition—taking the substance would lead to their death within five years.

The results of the survey, which was anonymous and confidential, suggested that a significant number of athletes would be willing to take the performance-enhancing substance, even with the knowledge that it would lead to their premature death. This raised ethical questions about the lengths some athletes might be willing to go to achieve success and the pressure they might feel to excel in highly competitive environments.

Goldman’s Dilemma highlights concerns about the use of performance-enhancing drugs in sports, the potential health risks associated with such substances, and the ethical considerations surrounding the pursuit of victory at any cost. It also underscores the importance of addressing the pressures and expectations placed on athletes and the need for strict anti-doping measures to maintain the integrity of sports competitions.

Come up with a list of reasons an athlete might use a supplement.… even when some supplements come with risks, and have limited evidence of performance enhancement… let me know in the comments!

1 Like
2

One reason athletes might use it is the desire to gain even a slight advantage over opponents, it can be a strong motivator, sometimes overshadowing potential health concerns.

Another reason could be the influence of peers and the sports environment. Athletes might feel compelled to use supplements because others within their circle or team are doing so, creating a culture where it’s perceived as necessary for success :woman_shrugging:

1 Like
3

Yes, exactly! It’s certainly a big motivation for lots of athletes.

Some other reasons might be,

  • To correct micronutrient deficiencies (Vitamin D inadequate in winter months, Vitamin B12 for vegan athletes, Iron for female athletes, Ferrate for pregnant athletes)
  • To lower perceived rate of exertion (Caffeine)
  • To increase recovery between sessions
  • Recovering from illness / injury
  • Convenience
  • Financial purposes
1 Like